diff --git a/site/src/routes/repl/archive.json.js b/site/src/routes/repl/archive.json.js
index 6a000c4377..f09fb8fadf 100644
--- a/site/src/routes/repl/archive.json.js
+++ b/site/src/routes/repl/archive.json.js
@@ -12,10 +12,14 @@ export async function get(req, res) {
 
 	const offset = req.query.offset || 0;
 	const rows = await query(`
-		select g.uid, g.name, coalesce(g.updated_at, g.created_at) as updated_at
+		select
+			g.uid,
+			g.name,
+			coalesce(g.updated_at, g.created_at) as updated_at,
+			g.created_at
 		from gists g
 		where g.user_id = $1
-		order by g.updated_at desc, g.created_at desc
+		order by coalesce(g.updated_at, g.created_at) desc
 		limit 20
 		offset $2
 	`, [user.id, offset]);